Soh Kam Yung reviewed The Hobbit by J. R. R. Tolkien
A lovely adaptation of the novel into graphic form
4 stars
A lovely graphic novel adaptation of Tolkien's book about the adventures of the Hobbit, Bilbo Baggins, as he joins a group of dwarves led by Thorin Oakenshield on a journey to reclaim their kingdom from the dragon Smaug. Gandalf, the wizard, helps them in their adventures while they are aided and hindered by trolls, elves, goblins, wargs, a shape-shifter and men. But it is one meeting that Bilbo has with the creature, Gollum, deep in the heart of the mountains, that will have world changing consequences.
This is a revised version of the original graphic novel by the artist. Since I do not have the original graphic novel, I am unable to compare them to see what changes have been done. The artist states the revision was done to make the flow of the content better now that publication restrictions that applied to the original version have been removed.
…A lovely graphic novel adaptation of Tolkien's book about the adventures of the Hobbit, Bilbo Baggins, as he joins a group of dwarves led by Thorin Oakenshield on a journey to reclaim their kingdom from the dragon Smaug. Gandalf, the wizard, helps them in their adventures while they are aided and hindered by trolls, elves, goblins, wargs, a shape-shifter and men. But it is one meeting that Bilbo has with the creature, Gollum, deep in the heart of the mountains, that will have world changing consequences.
This is a revised version of the original graphic novel by the artist. Since I do not have the original graphic novel, I am unable to compare them to see what changes have been done. The artist states the revision was done to make the flow of the content better now that publication restrictions that applied to the original version have been removed.
Included at the end of this edition is some background on how the artist came to create the novel, and the kind of artwork he decided to use, and some details on how he created the characters of Bilbo Baggins, Gandalf, and the dwarves.
Apart from a minor glitch, the graphic novel closely follows the book. The glitch occurs when the dwarves are captured by the spiders and are hanging from trees imprisoned in webs. Bilbo finds them and proceeds to rescue them. Missing at this point is the actual rescue, with Bilbo distracting the spiders, then cutting the dwarves free of their webs. In the book, Bilbo finds the dwarves and in the next scene, they are free and trying to escape from the spiders. A strange ommission in the book.
Otherwise, a good adaptation of the novel, with artwork that enhances the story and helps put the reader into the story.