Sally Strange reviewed The Thick and the Lean by Chana Porter
Food, sex, and fashion - the core of any good scifi tale
5 stars
All science fiction is about the moment in which it is written. People who reject or overlook this truism may not appreciate "The Thick and the Lean." The similarities between our world and the one Porter creates are many, and they are pointed. Capitalism merging with religion to oppress the people, particularly the indigenous and the disabled. Men exploiting women under the guise of sexual liberation. Even a climate crisis, though this one is caused by the converging orbits of the planet's two moons. But the author spices these similarities with enough points of departure that it gives the reader a fresh perspective on all of them.
That this fresh perspective is distinctly feminine, queer, literary, and revolutionary is what makes the book superlative in my eyes. The weaving together of the stories of three women from vastly different places and times is expertly done, and the descriptions of …
All science fiction is about the moment in which it is written. People who reject or overlook this truism may not appreciate "The Thick and the Lean." The similarities between our world and the one Porter creates are many, and they are pointed. Capitalism merging with religion to oppress the people, particularly the indigenous and the disabled. Men exploiting women under the guise of sexual liberation. Even a climate crisis, though this one is caused by the converging orbits of the planet's two moons. But the author spices these similarities with enough points of departure that it gives the reader a fresh perspective on all of them.
That this fresh perspective is distinctly feminine, queer, literary, and revolutionary is what makes the book superlative in my eyes. The weaving together of the stories of three women from vastly different places and times is expertly done, and the descriptions of food, sex, and even the clothing choices of various characters are loving, detailed, and lush. Somehow the entire story is wistful, angry, and cozy all at once.