Reviews and Comments

coral

coral@bookwyrm.world

Joined 1 month ago

Your bird friend Coral, a library web developer and systems administrator, working remotely. Runs (despite their best efforts) on caffeine and rage.

This link opens in a pop-up window

None

I'm not buying the third book in this series, though I'll probably borrow it from the library, because a friend of mine wants to discuss the series.

I won't put any more money into Howey's hands, because I am PISSED about the way Howey, who wrote a fairly gender-balanced first book, silenced and disempowered the women in this one.

.

.

.

.

.
*** SPOILER SPOILER SPOILER SPOILER ***

.

.

So, in one of the timelines, all of the women are asleep. Literally asleep. I kept reading, though, thinking "Well, maybe this is necessary for some kind of narrative device." But, no, it's only necessary so that we can be surprised by the villainy of one of the only two women who get to wake up, the whore in the classic virgin/whore dichotomy that so many male writers rely on.

One timeline has to be from a male …

None

I love birds and really enjoy learning about them, especially about bird behavior, so it was with great excitement that I agreed to review this book. And overall, it is enjoyable and educational, full of interesting facts and anecdotes, not only about birds but about numerous other animals, including humans.

I was disappointed, though, to see a scientist, who so lovingly describes bird behavior with a great eye for detail and nuance, fall back on unflattering generalizations about female humans, such as his statement that "males with more possessions and creativity are generally more likely to attract women" and some evolutionary biological discussion of men and women having been "segregated in their work," leading to a lack of fight-or-flight impulse in the latter. These statements were unnecessary, insulting, and distracting. Without them—and a fair number of unnecessary "he"s when referring to scientists—this would have been a really fantastic book.