Children of Memory

David Scrimshaw reviewed Children of Memory by Adrian Tchaikovsky

A fascinating universe

5 stars

I really enjoyed this book. Even though it was confusing until we learned what was going on.

Having read most of Adrian Tchaikovsky's books, I'm amazed at the breadth of styles he uses and worlds he has us inhabit.

He's also gifted at writing aliens that are truly alien and characters who don't all thing the way I imagine he thinks. Here the aliens descended from Earth animals, but they do think differently from humans and Tchaikovsky does an interesting exploration of what intelligence and sentience means.

People seem to suspect that this is the last volume in this series. It feels like this might be the case. I would be entirely happy if there is another. But then, I'd also like more volumes in other series he's written and even sequels to some of his "stand-alone" novels. So, I'm good with letting him decide where to take us next.

Konstantinos Kavourakis reviewed Children of Memory by Adrian Tchaikovsky (Children of Time, #3)

The weakest of the trilogy

3 stars

Although not bad sci-fi its connection to the previous 2 books is rather loose. The third book takes an entirely different direction, some parts resembling westerns depicting the early pioneers of the time. The weakest of the three books, 3/5 for me.

Flippin' 'Eck, Reader reviewed Children of Memory by Adrian Tchaikovsky

Worth persevering

4 stars

This is the third -- and I believe final -- installment in Adrian Tchaikovsky's acclaimed Children of Time series.

The action once again moves on to another alien world but with many of the same characters and species from the earlier two books. And of course we are introduced to additional new intelligences, as you'd expect from the earlier stories' trajectories.

However it took me well over half the book to really get into it. The multiple plots seemed not only hard to keep track of, but self-contradictory at times as well. Eventually everything does fall into place and there are enough plot twists to keep you intrigued right to the end, but there were definitely times when I had to force myself to keep reading as the frustration was starting to get too much.

I'm glad I kept going, though. In the last third of the book many of …

This is the third -- and I believe final -- installment in Adrian Tchaikovsky's acclaimed Children of Time series.

The action once again moves on to another alien world but with many of the same characters and species from the earlier two books. And of course we are introduced to additional new intelligences, as you'd expect from the earlier stories' trajectories.

However it took me well over half the book to really get into it. The multiple plots seemed not only hard to keep track of, but self-contradictory at times as well. Eventually everything does fall into place and there are enough plot twists to keep you intrigued right to the end, but there were definitely times when I had to force myself to keep reading as the frustration was starting to get too much.

I'm glad I kept going, though. In the last third of the book many of the earlier confusion gets resolved, and that's what's bumped it up from a three-star to a four-star review.

It is ultimately a good book in the end, although it's definitely more openly philosophical and introspective than the previous two. If you like Tchaikovsky's work and are prepared to stick with it, this is rewarding.

Matthew reviewed Children of Memory by Adrian Tchaikovsky

Fascinating continuation of the Children series

4 stars

Really enjoyed this. Wish Bookwyrm allowed for half stars - would be 4.5 here. So many interesting ideas, explored well. Always kept me guessing what was happening, and the story unwound at a (mostly) pleasing pace. A slow pace, mind - not one for action-science fiction fans; this is very thinky, philosophical stuff.

A couple of the chapters didn't quite work for me - more narrative background than story, they contributed to the overall understanding but I found them harder to get through than the rest - but Tchaikovsky really does explore some fascinating concepts here and I recommend this one for anyone into this slower style of science fiction.

SocProf reviewed Children of Memory by Adrian Tchaikovsky

A worthy addition to this series

5 stars

I have been a huge fan of this series ever since I read Children of Time. This one is on a par with it. The premise is the same: an Earth Ark ship on its way to a new planet, supposed to have been terraformed in anticipation of human colonists, escaping a dying Earth. In line with the Gilgamesh of Children of Time, this one is called the Enkidu, on its way to a planet called Imir. but they are not the only one. There is also an expedition from the Humans and their non-human allies (portiids, octopi, and the new addition: corvids). There is, I think, a greater sense of tragedy to this one, with a mystery at its center. The ending is ambiguous so I'm not sure whether there will be another "Children of..." entry or not. Either way, this one was a page-turner.

Andy P.

rated it

May 15

Subjects