This is probably a better book than I am rating it at, but I just didn't like spending time in this world.
Reviews and Comments
An avid sci-fi and fantasy reader who sometimes does historical fiction or even mainstream.
You might notice that most of my reviews are 5 stars. That's because if I start reading a book that doesn't engage me, I stop reading it. Life is too short. I've realized that it's not fair to review a book I haven't read and nobody really needs to hear why I didn't get into a book especially when they might like it.
My goals with reviews are to be brief and give other potential readers an idea of why they might like the book. I leave it to the marketing people and other reviewers to describe the plots.
This link opens in a pop-up window
David Scrimshaw reviewed The Amateurs by Liz Harmer
Review of 'The Amateurs' on 'Storygraph'
3 stars
This is probably a better book than I am rating it at, but I just didn't like spending time in this world.
David Scrimshaw reviewed Some of the Kinder Planets by Tim Wynne-Jones
David Scrimshaw reviewed Without Fail (Jack Reacher) by Lee Child (Jack Reacher (6))
Review of 'Without Fail (Jack Reacher)' on 'Storygraph'
4 stars
I need to space out my Jack Reacher books. Reading them too close together puts me in a mental space where I think everyone I see is ready to do violence to me.
Unlike Jack Reacher, I'm not ready to handle it if they do. So the tension I feel probably doesn't do me any good.
I need to space out my Jack Reacher books. Reading them too close together puts me in a mental space where I think everyone I see is ready to do violence to me.
Unlike Jack Reacher, I'm not ready to handle it if they do. So the tension I feel probably doesn't do me any good.
David Scrimshaw reviewed Player One by Douglas Coupland
Review of 'Player One' on 'Storygraph'
4 stars
This was interesting for a while but then I just wanted it to be over with and to find out what had happened.
Coupland ends the book by telling you what happened to everyone, breaking the writing rule of "don't tell, show".
It wasn't very engaging, but since I'd reached the point where I wanted it to be over, I was okay with it.
This was interesting for a while but then I just wanted it to be over with and to find out what had happened.
Coupland ends the book by telling you what happened to everyone, breaking the writing rule of "don't tell, show".
It wasn't very engaging, but since I'd reached the point where I wanted it to be over, I was okay with it.
David Scrimshaw reviewed Player One by Douglas Coupland
Review of 'Player One' on 'Storygraph'
4 stars
This was interesting for a while but then I just wanted it to be over with and to find out what had happened.
Coupland ends the book by telling you what happened to everyone, breaking the writing rule of "don't tell, show".
It wasn't very engaging, but since I'd reached the point where I wanted it to be over, I was okay with it.
This was interesting for a while but then I just wanted it to be over with and to find out what had happened.
Coupland ends the book by telling you what happened to everyone, breaking the writing rule of "don't tell, show".
It wasn't very engaging, but since I'd reached the point where I wanted it to be over, I was okay with it.
David Scrimshaw reviewed Memory by K.J. Parker (The Scavenger Trilogy)
Review of 'Memory' on 'Storygraph'
5 stars
For a simple guy like me, this volume was much easier to read. Poldarn gets to learn who he is and we usually know who is who.
Not exactly an uplifting tail, but it's nothing like any other fantasy series out there.
For a simple guy like me, this volume was much easier to read. Poldarn gets to learn who he is and we usually know who is who.
Not exactly an uplifting tail, but it's nothing like any other fantasy series out there.
David Scrimshaw reviewed Full fathom five by Max Gladstone
Review of 'Full fathom five' on 'Storygraph'
5 stars
This is a great fantasy series.
And so far, all the books end properly, so if you can't read the next book right away, it's all right. I mean, you will want to read the next one because you'll want to spend more time with some of the characters, but it will be okay if you have to wait a while.
This is a great fantasy series.
And so far, all the books end properly, so if you can't read the next book right away, it's all right. I mean, you will want to read the next one because you'll want to spend more time with some of the characters, but it will be okay if you have to wait a while.
David Scrimshaw reviewed Blackfish City by Sam J Miller
Review of 'Blackfish City' on 'Storygraph'
4 stars
This was fun. Reminiscent of Neal Stephenson.
No talking cats or mice, but people bonded with animals. If there's a sequel, we can hope someone to bond with a cat or a rodent.
This was fun. Reminiscent of Neal Stephenson.
No talking cats or mice, but people bonded with animals. If there's a sequel, we can hope someone to bond with a cat or a rodent.
David Scrimshaw reviewed All These Worlds by Dennis E. Taylor (Bobiverse, #3)
David Scrimshaw reviewed Blackfish City by Sam J. Miller
Review of 'Blackfish City' on 'Storygraph'
4 stars
This was fun. Reminiscent of Neal Stephenson.
No talking cats or mice, but people bonded with animals. If there's a sequel, we can hope someone to bond with a cat or a rodent.
This was fun. Reminiscent of Neal Stephenson.
No talking cats or mice, but people bonded with animals. If there's a sequel, we can hope someone to bond with a cat or a rodent.
David Scrimshaw reviewed Full Fathom Five by Max Gladstone
Review of 'Full Fathom Five' on 'Storygraph'
5 stars
This is a great fantasy series.
And so far, all the books end properly, so if you can't read the next book right away, it's all right. I mean, you will want to read the next one because you'll want to spend more time with some of the characters, but it will be okay if you have to wait a while.
This is a great fantasy series.
And so far, all the books end properly, so if you can't read the next book right away, it's all right. I mean, you will want to read the next one because you'll want to spend more time with some of the characters, but it will be okay if you have to wait a while.
David Scrimshaw reviewed All these worlds by Dennis E. Taylor
David Scrimshaw reviewed Four Roads Cross by Max Gladstone (Craft sequence)
David Scrimshaw reviewed The Gum Thief by Douglas Coupland
Review of 'The Gum Thief' on 'Storygraph'
4 stars
This book has a novel inside a novel and then... there's a novel inside the novel that is inside the novel!
I don't really know if that's a good thing. I was not very interested in the third level down. I cared about the characters in the main novel. Maybe it was deliberate that I wouldn't care so much the further levels down.
The main novel characters know each other from the Staples they work at. That was definitely fun.
And I'm happy to report that this book was in my big pile of books to read and now I can put it in one of the nearby little free libraries.
This book has a novel inside a novel and then... there's a novel inside the novel that is inside the novel!
I don't really know if that's a good thing. I was not very interested in the third level down. I cared about the characters in the main novel. Maybe it was deliberate that I wouldn't care so much the further levels down.
The main novel characters know each other from the Staples they work at. That was definitely fun.
And I'm happy to report that this book was in my big pile of books to read and now I can put it in one of the nearby little free libraries.














