Reviews and Comments

David Scrimshaw Locked account

DScrimshaw@bookwyrm.world

Joined 4 months, 1 week ago

An avid sci-fi and fantasy reader who sometimes does historical fiction or even mainstream.

You might notice that most of my reviews are 5 stars. That's because if I start reading a book that doesn't engage me, I stop reading it. Life is too short. I've realized that it's not fair to review a book I haven't read and nobody really needs to hear why I didn't get into a book especially when they might like it.

My goals with reviews are to be brief and give other potential readers an idea of why they might like the book. I leave it to the marketing people and other reviewers to describe the plots.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Review of 'Local Habitation (Toby Daye Book 2)' on 'Storygraph'

4 stars

Ms McGuire's Wayward Children series is incredible.

After two volumes, I wouldn't rank the October Daye series so highly. But if you're into tormented private investigators connected to the magical world and you've read all the books and stories about Harry Dresden, it's not bad.

It's perhaps a hundred years in the future and E. A. Smithe is "a clone …

Review of 'A borrowed man' on 'Storygraph'

5 stars

The narrator and protagonist of this book is a "re-clone". He is the clone with memory prints of a mystery writer. Now he is a "thing" with no legal rights who resides in a library and his continued existence depends on people consulting him or checking him out from time to time.

With this sort of world-building, I would have expected some sort of sweeping tale where the hero starts a revolution so that people like him get legal rights.

But no. He just does the best he can with the situations that come his way in the constraints he has.

His limited worldview reminded me in a good way of Martha Wells Murderbot.

Tom Holt: In Your Dreams (2005) 4 stars

Review of 'In Your Dreams' on 'Storygraph'

4 stars

These books by Tom Holt are growing on me.

I started reading them because he's also K.J. Parker.

The Tom Holt books seem to be generally lighter with more raw humour.

I think of myself as not being into dark stuff, but I maybe prefer the K.J. Parker books so far.

Still I plan to read all of them eventually.

K.J. Parker: Prosper's Demon (Paperback, 2020, Tor.com) 5 stars

In a botched demonic extraction, they say the demon feels it ten times worse than …

Review of "Prosper's Demon" on 'Storygraph'

5 stars

This is a tight, crisp story that's not like any other fantasy story I've read.

You can count on a K.J. Parker story having an interesting protagonist who you perhaps should not be rooting for.

In Manhattan, a young grad student gets off the train and realizes he doesn't remember …

Review of 'City We Became' on 'Storygraph'

4 stars

The stuff going on in this novel has a multi-verse explanation, but I'd say you have to call it fantasy.

If you like an interesting story that has just about nothing in common with other fantasy stories you've read, this is a good choice.

I think it would be particularly fun for people who feel connected to New York City.